Few governance questions generate more confusion in Michigan community associations than the difference between a director and an officer. Owners cast a ballot at the annual meeting believing they are electing a president or a treasurer. Managers field calls from residents demanding that the board fire the president, and from officers who believe their title carries spending authority the board never granted. The distinction is not academic. It determines who is elected and by whom, who can be removed and by what vote, and who has authority to bind the association.
The Statutory Starting Point
Nearly every Michigan community association, condominium or otherwise, is organized as a Michigan nonprofit corporation, so the Michigan Nonprofit Corporation Act (MCL 450.2101 et seq.) supplies the default framework. Two sections in particular deserve our attention.
The first places management with the board. Under MCL 450.2501(1), “The business and affairs of a corporation shall be managed by or under the direction of its board, except as otherwise provided in this act or in its articles of incorporation.”
The second creates a separate set of positions. MCL 450.2531(1) provides that “The officers of a corporation shall consist of a president, secretary, treasurer, and, if desired, a chairperson of the board, 1 or more vice presidents, and any other officers as prescribed in the bylaws or determined by the board. Unless otherwise provided in the articles of incorporation or bylaws, the board shall elect or appoint the officers.”
Officers are therefore not a subset of the board. They are separate corporate positions, filled by the board unless the association’s articles or bylaws provide otherwise. For condominiums, the operational detail comes from the recorded documents: MCL 559.153 (Section 53 of Michigan’s Condominium Act) provides that “The administration of a condominium project shall be governed by bylaws recorded as part of the master deed, or as provided in the master deed.”
The Community Elects Directors; the Directors Elect Officers
Typical bylaws provide that at the annual meeting “there shall be elected by ballot or acclamation of the owners a Board of Directors” in accordance with the bylaw article governing the board. That is the whole of what the ballot does. It selects the individuals who will occupy seats on the board, and it assigns none of them to an office. A candidate statement like “vote for me as your next treasurer” misdescribes the ballot and creates an expectation the board is under no obligation to honor.
Once seated, the board fills the officer positions. Common bylaw language reads: “The Board of Directors shall appoint the Association’s officers annually and all officers shall hold office at the Board’s pleasure.” Bylaws commonly pair this with a requirement that a newly elected board hold its first meeting within a short window after the election, often ten days, and that organizational meeting is ordinarily where offices are filled.
One qualifier deserves emphasis. MCL 450.2531(1) makes board appointment the default, not an absolute rule; the articles or bylaws may provide otherwise. If your documents have the membership elect officers directly, the removal analysis below changes.
Officers Generally Need Not Be Directors
This is the point that surprises boards most often. A representative designation provision reads: “The principal Association officers are a president, vice president, secretary, and treasurer. The Directors may appoint other officers as may be necessary. Any two offices except that of president and vice president may be held by one person. The President must be a member of the Board of Directors.” This language tells us two things. The president must be a director, a restriction that is common but comes from the documents rather than from the statute. The remaining offices carry no comparable requirement in bylaws of this type, so an owner who is not a director can be appointed secretary or treasurer.
Two cautions belong with this. A non-director officer does not vote on board matters. Board quorum and board action are measured by directors. Typical bylaws provide that a majority of the directors then in office constitutes a quorum and that the acts of a majority of the directors present at a meeting at which there is a quorum are the acts of the board. A treasurer who is not a director may keep the books, report to the board, and sign instruments as the board authorizes, but does not count toward quorum and does not cast a board vote.
Also, the qualification requirements imposed on directors do not automatically extend to officers. Bylaws frequently require that directors be owners, trustees of trusts owning units, or officers, directors, members, or employees of business entities owning units, while the officer article imposes no comparable requirement. That flexibility can be useful. An association may find, for example, that a member’s spouse who is a CPA, or another community member with financial experience, is willing to serve as treasurer even though that person is not an owner and could not serve as a director. If your board wants officers limited to owners, the documents need to say so.
Removing an Officer Is Not Removing a Director
Here the two roles come apart most sharply.
Officers serve at the will of the board. MCL 450.2535(1) provides that “An officer elected or appointed by the board may be removed by the board with or without cause. An officer elected by the shareholders or members may be removed, with or without cause, only by vote of the shareholders or members.” Bylaws reinforce this with language providing that officers hold office at the board’s pleasure. A board that appointed an officer may therefore remove that officer by board vote, with or without cause, and need not justify the decision to the officer or to the community. Some documents layer additional procedure on top of that authority, such as a requirement that the proposed removal appear in the notice of the meeting or that the officer be given an opportunity to be heard, and those requirements control where they appear. Confirm what your own documents require before the vote.
Directors are removed by the membership. MCL 450.2511(1) provides that the members of a corporation organized on a membership basis may remove one or more directors with or without cause unless the articles of incorporation provide that directors may be removed only for cause. Association bylaws then supply the mechanics. Bylaws commonly allow removal at a duly called annual or special meeting by the affirmative vote of more than fifty percent of all owners in good standing, with a successor elected at that meeting to serve the balance of the removed director’s term, and with the affected director given an opportunity to be heard.
Now put the two together, because this is the scenario that generates the phone calls. Suppose the board is dissatisfied with how the president presides over meetings. The board may remove that person from the office of president and appoint a successor. The former president nonetheless remains a director, with full voting rights, until the owners vote to remove the director or the term expires. The board has changed responsibilities, but it has not changed who sits at the table.
The relationship runs in only one direction. Because the president must be a director under bylaws like these, a person who ceases to be a director can no longer serve as president, but removal from an office never, by itself, removes anyone from the board.
Why the Distinction Matters Beyond Titles
Authority. The board acts; officers carry out what the board has authorized. Bylaws commonly provide that association funds may be withdrawn only upon the check or order of those officers, employees, or agents designated by board resolution. A title alone is not a standing grant of spending authority.
Duty. Both roles carry the same standard of conduct. Under MCL 450.2541(1), a director or officer must discharge their duties in good faith, with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances, and in a manner they reasonably believe is in the best interests of the corporation. A non-director treasurer is a corporate officer subject to that standard, not a volunteer bookkeeper operating outside the governance structure.
Records and coverage. The annual report filed with the Corporations Division lists the names and addresses of the president, secretary, treasurer, and directors (MCL 450.2911). When an office changes mid-year, update the corporate record and the banking signature cards, and record the officer change in the minutes separately from any change in board composition. Confirm with your agent that the directors and officers policy defines insured persons broadly enough to reach officers who are not directors.
Practical Takeaways for Boards
- Describe the ballot accurately. Election materials should say that owners are electing directors and that the board will select officers afterward.
- Hold the organizational meeting promptly. If the bylaws require a first meeting of the new board within a set number of days, calendar it before the annual meeting adjourns.
- Check for added removal procedure. Officers ordinarily serve at the board’s pleasure, but confirm whether your documents impose notice or hearing requirements before the board votes on removal.
- Do not treat a board vote as a director removal. If the concern is a director’s continued service, the path runs through a membership vote at a properly noticed meeting, at the percentage the bylaws require.
- Authorize by resolution. Designate who may sign checks, execute contracts, and access accounts, and update those resolutions when offices change.
The rule is short enough to state in a sentence: the community elects directors, and the directors elect officers. Everything else follows from it. An officer appointed by the board serves at the board’s pleasure and may be removed by board vote, with or without cause, and that removal leaves the person’s board seat untouched. Removing a director generally requires a vote of the membership at a properly noticed meeting, at the threshold the governing documents specify.
These principles reflect the statutory defaults and language common to Michigan community association documents, but the controlling terms are the ones in your own master deed, bylaws, declaration, or articles of incorporation, which vary in meaningful ways. Boards should confirm the provisions that apply to their community and consult legal counsel before removing an officer, contesting a director’s seat, or restructuring how offices are filled.